patching...
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

Upper Dublin Music Parents to Meet to Discuss Budget Shortfall

The Upper Dublin Marching Band Parents Association will hold a public meeting tonight.

 

 

Parents of music students in the Upper Dublin School District are quite concerned about the impact of proposed cuts to the school district budget.

A preliminary budget presented to the Upper Dublin School Board on Monday, Jan. 14 shows a $2.8 million budget shortfall for the upcoming school year. To balance the school budget, wide, sweeping cuts in faculty and programs are being proposed. One potential cut under consideration involves the demotion of the entire faculty of the school district music program to part time positions. This would include band, choir, and orchestra faculty at the elementary, middle and high school levels.  The Upper Dublin Marching Band Parents Association (UDMBPA) is worried about the staggering impact of such cuts on the quality of music education in the Upper Dublin schools. It fears that a part time faculty could mean the loss of countless high quality music programs that are points of pride for the entire Upper Dublin community.

A The UDMBPA will host a public meeting tonight to advocate for music education in the Upper Dublin school district. The discussion will include the implications of the proposed budget cuts with an eye towards identifying alternative and creative solutions that may preserve and protect the district's music programs.

The meeting will be held at 7 p.m. at the Upper Dublin High School Cafeteria at 800 Loch Alsh Ave. in Fort Washington. The meeting is open to the entire community, parents, grandparents, students, alumni, and anyone interested in the future of music education in Upper Dublin.  

Parents of current and future elementary, middle and high school students, and parents of students in the choral, band and orchestra music programs are especially encouraged to attend. Chris Dowdell, president of the UDMBPA said “Luckily, the budget proposal is still ‘preliminary,’ and can still be influenced by community input.” It is hoped that the community can find another way to meet the current budget crisis without damaging the music program."

Marching Band parents certainly know first hand the huge number of hours devoted by the music faculty to supporting quality music programs in Upper Dublin. Music parents are concerned that the music faculty will not be able to sustain that level of involvement if they are worried about shoring up their own family financial security. Faculty members may have to take on outside work on evenings and weekends to make up for their lost income and benefits. This would mean that they would no longer be available to sponsor the wide array of music ensembles and music programs that are currently the pride of the district. The music program would be reduced to school day classroom instruction in a smaller number of classes. Music programs that rehearse and perform outside of school hours could disappear.

The following are just a few of the programs that could be impacted by the loss of faculty time: Upper Dublin Marching Cardinals, UD Swing Jazz Band, the Men's, Women's, Chamber and Show Choirs, VOX Jazz Choir, Pit Orchestra, Sophisticated Strings, Indoor Color Guard and Indoor Drumline.

The lack of faculty sponsors could mean that Upper Dublin would no longer be able to participate in or host high visibility music programs such as the Montgomery County Honor's Band on either the middle or high school levels or the Spectacle in Sound Marching Band Competition. The competitions that celebrate our most accomplished musicians would be unavailable: District, Region, and State Band, District, Region, and State Orchestra, and Suburban and District Choir. These are the ensembles that future music and performance majors need on their transcripts to find placements at top college music programs.

Several research studies confirm that the study of music influences the development of the growing child's brain and is associated with innovative thinking, spatial reasoning, and creative problem solving, skills that will be prized in the workforce of the future.  An analysis of College Board data has shown a strong correlation between arts education and higher SAT scores. Students who participated in arts education for four or more years had combined SAT scores 101 points higher than students who did not participate in arts education.  

The UDMBPA notes that every student in the district currently benefits from exposure and access to the study of music each year from kindergarten onwards through high school.  Furthermore, the Upper Dublin School District was recently named tenth in the state of Pennsylvania for SAT scores among all public schools.  This certainly suggests that the district's strong music program may have played a key role in the history of academic excellence in the district. The UDMBPA strongly believes that accomplishments in music have been a significant reason why Upper Dublin graduates in every discipline have consistently found themselves welcomed and rewarded by the best college programs in the country. 

--

Written by Deborah Carver and submitted by Chris Dowdell, UDMBPA President, and Deborah Carver, UDMBPA Public Relations Secretary

Related Topics: Upper Dublin Marching Band, Upper Dublin Music Parents Association, and upper dublin school district

JM

7:43 am on Tuesday, January 22, 2013

Does anyone now what percentage of student body are currently involved with the music program?

Reply
Comment_arrow

David Plasket

12:50 pm on Thursday, January 31, 2013

I have no idea of the percentage of the student body in music but I do know that there were more students in The Honors Orchestra than a typical sport team.
D Plasket

qdogPa

2:54 pm on Tuesday, January 22, 2013

Imagine the uproar if the Sports program and staff were cut to PT or some sports simply eliminated?

Reply

Don M

3:21 pm on Tuesday, January 22, 2013

qdog, though you aren't the first not to research the subject first, these are clearly on the table as proposed cuts as well... elimination of stipends (i.e., payments to teachers to coach school teams) and the possibility of instituting player participation fees to offset equipment and operating costs.

People are talking about forming booster clubs like we used to many years ago so those costs are absorbed by those benefiting. I had a visitor the other day from someone seeking my opinion on it and I'd help support it even though I don't have kids in the program.

The district should keep varsity and JV but cut 9th grade sports, institute a $50-100 player fee (just like parents pay for club sports), and require players to pay for their own uniforms and equipment. Booster clubs can help pick up the additional expense for qualifying players who cannot afford it along with fees for security, maintenance and utilities.

Now where's all that uproar you suggested would happen? Sounds like people talking about ways to help instead of whining for more handouts.

Reply

qdogPa

8:22 pm on Tuesday, January 22, 2013

Don M, i am well versed in this issue..my point is the athletic program costs significantly more to operate then the music program.If both programs were cut by equal percentages, i thhink it could be expected the uproar would be significant from sports side of equation...I think instituting player fees is a start, as is forming booster clubs.. However to think a booster club can raise the monies necessary for maintenance,utilities,et al is a mistaken belief...

Reply

Stop with the Taxes

9:16 pm on Tuesday, January 22, 2013

These cuts are nothing compared to what is coming. This board is hiding the fact that the deficit will be even bigger next year. Look at this year’s budget, $2.7 million is being covered by the fund balance which is run to $8,000 by the end of the year. So next year that money will need to get made up. They have already told us that Teacher retirement payments will go up next year, tax appeals which we know are significant will come due and further cuts are expected from the State. Pladus is just hiding everything waiting to dump in into the next Superintendents’ lap. We should be making much bigger cuts or we will be talking about the same thing next year.
As for Booster fund raising, forget about it. As a parent you cannot raise money and give it to a specific sport, say football for example. That would be a Title IX violation, just ask Wissahickon. If boosters raise money it has to go into a general pot to be shared by all. That makes specific booster fundraising impossible to get parents behind. Before you say it, I know different teams fund raise today, but they are violating Title IX. The past UD AD just kept her head in the sand.

Reply

Joe Koenig

1:14 am on Wednesday, January 23, 2013

All the complaining (real and justified in many instances) will do little good as the District (and many others) are facing similar financial constraints. While there are some things the Board has had direct control over, that is the Teacher's contract, the size and cost of the High School, many of the issues they cannot affect. The Teacher's Pension plan is in disarray after over 20 years of theft by both R's and D's.
There are long term solutions to this problem, but require political courage, and an implemetation of Defined contribution plans. Holding tight on the next teacher's contract, even some reduced benefits. Perhaps an increase in the EIT. Until propery values rise, self provided income will remain stagnant, There is a proposal to radically alter how we pay for schools, but seems to be going newhere in the Legislature. The Govenor has actually increase the education budget the last two years, unfortunately much $$ has gone into shoring up PSERS. Another solution which the Board will propose in 2014 after school board elections, will be a referecdum to raise taxes. HOLD ONTO YOU HATS THEN!!!!!!!! Of course the Teachers' Union want to tax Marecellus Shale so the can retain their rising salaries. Don't be fooled, they are not looking out for your children.

Reply
Comment_arrow

sdaccos

11:10 pm on Saturday, February 2, 2013

Joe, Marecellus should be taxed at a reasonable rate like virtually every other state with similar natural resources. We could debate where that money should go but cushy deals for political friends of the governor isn't what the state needs right now.

Andi Lyn

10:22 am on Sunday, January 27, 2013

I wish we could somehow raise the extra cash without taxing our residents. Year after year of tax increases have quickly turned a supportive caring community into bitter and angry citizens.

Reply

Don M

11:14 am on Monday, January 28, 2013

Here's what I would like to hear from this discussion: solutions, not gripes. Reductions are INEVITABLE and EVERY program should be prepared to take a hit.

Times like this require leadership, not complaining, and though cuts will be felt deep within many families' hearts, they will find more traction proposing savings alongside their proposal to keep key programs and personnel. Assuming ANY program will be left fully intact and cuts deferred to another program should be laughable and immediately disregarded so I encourage this group to recognize ways to be part of the long-term solution.

Similarly I'd like to see the same from the athletics program, drama and fine arts program, language program and each student club. Furthermore I suggest the Board and Administration establish a culture of cooperation and solicit proposals from food service, maintenance, student services and other departments on ways they can participate as well.

I think this would go a long way toward winning back the support Andi Lyn accurately describes.

Reply

Jim

9:18 pm on Saturday, February 2, 2013

I believe the present and past township manager, present and past school board members and the Superintendent didn't do the their jobs and knew this was coming.
I believe the Teachers, Union represented and protected and darn well compensated, including generous benefits and a very generous pension, particularly for a nine month job, should make concessions and save the full time status of their colleagues. Non-core academics are damn well important and we all know. I work at 50+ hour week with no where near the pay, benefits, or pension,
at a comparable experience level paying for teachers to work in this district and resent what the lucky will be getting in increases with other cut to .8 and programs
cut. Grow up, give back, be grateful, remember all your colleagues and soldier on,
thinking about why you should be teaching, rather than what it gives to you.

Reply

sdaccos

11:17 pm on Saturday, February 2, 2013

Jim, my kids have had great teachers in the 9 years we've lived in the district. The vast majority of them are sincere, hardworking people who deal with incredible challenges from all directions. My experience has been they handle it with professionalism and care. This budget isn't an easy situation for anyone in the community but your begrudging them a living is pretty disappointing. Your resentment toward them speaks far more of you than it does of them.

Reply

Leave a comment